Next Generation Justice Platform

Leah Verghese and Surya Prakash from Daksh India talk to host Pavan Srinath about how a 21st-century justice platform can transform access to justice for Indians.

The justice system has made considerable advances in adoption of ICT given the scale of its operation and the large population whose needs it must meet. The design of information systems used by institutions such as the Indian judiciary, lawyers, government departments, police, and prison authorities, currently does not exploit the full extent of even current technical capabilities, owing to legislative, institutional, and resource constraints. This whitepaper series provides a roadmap for a transformation of the justice system that is not merely technologically oriented, but which sets goals which the process should fulfill, and proposes strategic, technical, legislative courses of action to reach these goals.

The Vision:

These goals are rooted in principle, rather than potential technical achievements, for two reasons. One is that technology must ultimately serve goals that are socially desirable, and the strategies adopted to fulfill them must then be based on morality and constitutional values. The other is that technology evolves at a pace where any vision for public institutions based on fulfilling technical capabilities will be rapidly outdated, and it makes more sense to tether the vision to something more permanent. These principles form the core of the first paper in the series ( Whitepaper Series on Next Generation Justice Platform, Paper 1: The Vision ), which describes a vision for a citizen-centric justice system.

Implementation and Transition:

The second paper in the series ( Whitepaper Series on Next Generation Justice Platform, Paper 2: Implementation and Transition )lays out the implementation strategies necessary to bridge the technical gap between current systems and those that would fulfill the vision described in Paper 1. These strategies are based on a consideration of the processes that are necessary for the design of the platform to meet its users’ needs and for the implementation to be successful, such as process re-engineering and stakeholder consultation. Effective planning of the sequencing of the implementation is essential for the platform’s success, and the paper discusses concerns regarding the phases of implementation based on the modules that the platform comprises, based on their functions and interdependencies.

Legal Framework:

The third paper in the series ( Whitepaper Series on Next Generation Justice Platform, Paper 3: Legal Framework ) proposes a legal framework to govern this public platform and an administration structure to manage it. Based on an assessment of past efforts in India and recent but less extensive efforts in other countries, the implementation of a public platform would benefit greatly from legislative backing. The paper proposes a legal framework that mandates migration to the platform; establishes the authority responsible for its creation, implementation, maintenance, and improvement; and provides for both disclosure and protection of judicial data to strike an appropriate balance between transparency and privacy.